Side Projects · Primly Community

how to validate a side project idea without building anything

pm_priya · 4 replies

I've started and abandoned maybe seven side projects in five years. The pattern was always the same: I'd get excited, spend 6-8 weeks building something, show it to a few people, and discover they didn't actually want it. Or they liked it but wouldn't pay for it.

The one that stuck -- a Notion template pack I now sell for $29 -- I validated in about 10 days without writing a line of code.

Here's exactly what I did:

Week 1. Manual version. Instead of building the thing, I manually did the thing for 3 strangers from Twitter DMs. They described their problem. I spent 30 minutes each creating what I would have built the tool to output. I charged nothing. I learned: (a) the actual job-to-be-done was different from what I thought, (b) what they found most valuable, (c) how long the manual version took me (useful for understanding if automation even makes sense).

Day 7. The landing page. Built a one-page site on Carrd in a few hours. Single clear problem statement, a mockup image, and a 'join waitlist' form. Put the price on it. No fake countdown timers, no 'beta launching soon' vagueness -- just the actual thing and the actual price.

Days 7-10. Traffic, not cold pitches. Posted in two subreddits where my target user hangs out, one HN thread that was tangentially relevant, and one Slack community. Not 'check out my thing' posts -- I answered existing questions and linked to the landing page once it was relevant. 74 page views in 3 days. 11 waitlist signups. 2 people emailed me asking 'can I pay now.'

That was enough signal. I built a v1 in 3 weeks and sold it to the waitlist first.

The part I got wrong on every previous project: I kept trying to validate interest instead of validating willingness to pay. Those are different things. Someone saying 'this is cool' is worth almost nothing. Someone typing their email into a form on a page that says it will cost them $29 is worth something.

4 replies

jordan_pm

The 'validate interest vs. willingness to pay' distinction is where most people lose the plot. I had a project with 600 waitlist signups. Converted to paying: 8. Different audiences, different conversion math.

consultant_cam

How did you find the three strangers to manually do the thing for? That's the step I always get stuck on. My network is small and I feel weird cold-asking people.

pm_priya

Twitter/X search for people complaining about the specific problem. Literal search: 'I hate [thing], does anyone have a better way.' They're already venting about it. DM them. Response rate was about 40%. People love talking about their problems, especially if you offer to help for free.

content_cole

The Carrd landing page with a real price is such good advice. I always defaulted to 'free beta' because it felt less risky. But 'free beta' attracts people who want free things, not customers.